Showing 2 results for Safety Barrier
Ehsan Ramezanifar, Kamran Gholamizadeh, Iraj Mohammadfam, Mostafa Mirzaei Aliabadi,
Volume 13, Issue 1 (3-2023)
Abstract
Introduction: Risk assessment is a scale for predicting reliability and can manage interactions between components and process variables. Moreover, the reliability of one component or barrier affects the overall risk of the system. Being one of the most critical safety barriers of the storage tank, the failures of Fixed Foam Systems (FFS) on demand can result in severe consequences. FFS, is of grave importance in decreasing the risks associated with fires and damages.
Material and Methods: This study aims to determine the probability of root causes related to FFS failure through Fuzzy Fault Tree Analysis (FFTA) to estimate system reliability. In conventional fault tree analysis, accurate data is usually used to assess the failure probability of basic events. Therefore, the introduced approaches were employed to quantify failure probabilities and uncertainty handling. Finally, system reliability was estimated according to the failure probability of the top event.
Results: The findings showed that 13 baseline events involved FFS performance. According to the results, failures of cable path and detection system (or resistance temperature detectors), set the activation switch (multi-position) incorrectly, and foam makers not continuously running are the three most critical basic events influencing the reliability of fixed foam systems. In addition, this paper estimated the system reliability at 0.8470.
Conclusion: The results showed that the FFTA could be used in matters such as reliability evaluation failure and risk assessment using experts’ judgment. This paper can also show the adaptation of the fuzzy approach to assess the failure probability of the basic event in the fault tree analysis (FTA).
Mr Alireza Azarmehri, Dr Ali Karimi, Dr Omran Ahmadi,
Volume 15, Issue 1 (3-2025)
Abstract
Introduction: Barriers are critical to mitigating risks and preventing catastrophic incidents in process industries. Human and Organizational Factors (HOFs) significantly impact safety barrier performance. This systematic review investigates existing frameworks and methods for assessing HOFs' influence on safety barrier performance.
Material and Methods: A systematic search was conducted across Scopus and Web of Science databases, adhering to the PRISMA guidelines. The search aimed to identify studies that presented methodologies for evaluating the impact of HOFs on safety barrier performance in process industries. Subsequently, data were extracted from the 16 included studies.
Results: The 16 studies included in this research presented methods and frameworks that examined the impact of human and organizational factors on various types of safety barriers, including technical, operational, and human barriers, across a wide range of industries such as oil and gas, chemical, and steel. Barrier and Operational Risk Analysis (BORA) was identified as the predominant framework among studies. Studies on operational and human barriers, which rely on human actions and procedures, often identified factors such as competence, training, communication, and supervision as influencing their performance. Regarding technical barriers, studies emphasized the need to assess factors such as maintenance management and procedures.
Conclusion: Thorough HOF assessment is crucial for developing effective risk management strategies in process industries. While progress has been made, the scope of assessment methods should be expanded to cover a wider range of industries and barrier types. To make assessments more objective, integrating data from multiple sources and using techniques based on fuzzy logic and Bayesian networks (BN) can help reduce reliance on expert judgment. The presented methods should also be complemented by dynamic assessment of HOFs with continuous monitoring to ensure the ongoing effectiveness of safety barriers.
